|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:17:43 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 35 Carrie Underwood 56 David Cook 29 David Archuleta 22 ------------------- 5th: Jordin Sparks 6th: Blake Lewis 7th: Fantasia Barrino 8th: Katherine McPhee 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Carrie -Kelly x2 I like Kelly. But not as much as the other three.  |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 16:18:21 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 36 Carrie Underwood 56 David Cook 29 David Archuleta 20 ------------------- 5th: Jordin Sparks 6th: Blake Lewis 7th: Fantasia Barrino 8th: Katherine McPhee 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Kelly -DA Kelly is SOOO much better than the Davids |
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:21:53 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 34 Carrie Underwood 57 David Cook 29 David Archuleta 20 ------------------- 5th: Jordin Sparks 6th: Blake Lewis 7th: Fantasia Barrino 8th: Katherine McPhee 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Carrie -Kelly x2 NOT TRUE  |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 16:32:49 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 35
Carrie Underwood 57
David Cook 29
David Archuleta 18
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-DA
VERY VERY TRUE! KELLY WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST AMERICAN IDOL!
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:34:58 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 33 Carrie Underwood 58 David Cook 29 David Archuleta 18 ------------------- 5th: Jordin Sparks 6th: Blake Lewis 7th: Fantasia Barrino 8th: Katherine McPhee 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Carrie -Kelly x2 CARRIE WILL ALWAYS BE THE BEST |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 16:40:42 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 34
Carrie Underwood 56
David Cook 29
David Archuleta 18
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+KELLY
-Carrie
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:41:46 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Carrie Underwood 57
David Cook 29
David Archuleta 18
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Carrie
-Kelly x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 16:48:10 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 33
Carrie Underwood 55
David Cook 29
David Archuleta 18
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-Carrie
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:49:33 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 31
Carrie Underwood 56
David Cook 29
David Archuleta 18
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Carrie
-Kelly x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 16:53:16 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Carrie Underwood 56
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 17
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+KELLY
-DA
-DC
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 16:54:18 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 30
Carrie Underwood 57
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 17
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Carrie
-Kelly x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 17:01:37 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 31
Carrie Underwood 57
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 15
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-DA x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 17:02:52 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 29
Carrie Underwood 58
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 15
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Carrie
-Kelly x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 29, 2008 17:05:23 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 29
Carrie Underwood 57
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 14
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-Carrie
-DA
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 29, 2008 17:43:12 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 27
Carrie Underwood 58
David Cook 28
David Archuleta 14
-------------------
5th: Jordin Sparks
6th: Blake Lewis
7th: Fantasia Barrino
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Carrie
-Kelly x2
|
|
