|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 27, 2008 22:43:13 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 9
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 8
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Katherine
-Fantasia x2
(you like fantasia THAT much??)
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 27, 2008 22:45:17 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 10
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 6
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Fantasia (Nah. I like her more then Katherine though, so...)
-Katherine x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 27, 2008 22:50:57 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 8
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 7
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Katherine
-Fantasia x2
I love Kat, and I personally find Fantasia annoying.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 27, 2008 22:52:20 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32 Fantasia Barino 9 Carrie Underwood 51 Jordin Sparks 20 David Cook 24 Katherine McPhee 5 Blake Lewis 24 David Archuleta 23 ------------------- 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Fantasia -Katherine x2 I personally like Katherine, but she don't stand out for me. Fantasia is just as good, and stands out. Plus her ability to put in such emotion doesn't hurt.  |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 27, 2008 22:53:25 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32 Fantasia Barino 7 Carrie Underwood 51 Jordin Sparks 20 David Cook 24 Katherine McPhee 6 Blake Lewis 24 David Archuleta 23 ------------------- 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Katherine -Fantasia x2 Fantasia isn't a bad singer, but I just do not like her for some reason. And Latoya was totally robbed that season  |
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 27, 2008 22:55:09 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32 Fantasia Barino 8 Carrie Underwood 51 Jordin Sparks 20 David Cook 24 Katherine McPhee 4 Blake Lewis 24 David Archuleta 23 ------------------- 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Fantasia -Katherine x2 Well, Katherine is going out first if we keep going on like this anyway so I ain't complaining. :lol: Everyone on the list besides Katherine are better than Fantasia. |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 27, 2008 22:58:27 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32 Fantasia Barino 6 Carrie Underwood 51 Jordin Sparks 20 David Cook 24 Katherine McPhee 5 Blake Lewis 24 David Archuleta 23 ------------------- 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Katherine -Fantasia x2 Ugg, could you please just go back to + Carrie again I won't let Kat fall before Fantasia AND Blake!!  |
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 27, 2008 23:00:34 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32 Fantasia Barino 7 Carrie Underwood 51 Jordin Sparks 20 David Cook 24 Katherine McPhee 3 Blake Lewis 24 David Archuleta 23 ------------------- 9th: Taylor Hicks 10th: Diana DeGarmo 11th. Bo Bice 12th: Justin Guarrini 13th: Clay Aiken 14th: Ruban Studdard +Fantasia -Katherine x2 Sorry. I'm not leaving till Katherine is out. |
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 27, 2008 23:38:30 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 5
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 4
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Katherine
-Fantasia x2
Ugg, oh well. Kat isn't my top fav out of the group at least.
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 28, 2008 8:42:39 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 6
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 2
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Fantasia
-Katherine x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 28, 2008 10:21:48 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 4
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 3
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Katherine
-Fantasia x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 28, 2008 11:29:42 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 32
Fantasia Barino 5
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 1
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Fantasia
-Katherine x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 28, 2008 16:27:15 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 33
Fantasia Barino 3
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 1
Blake Lewis 24
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-Fantasia x2
|
|
|
|
Post by Sally Carton on Nov 28, 2008 16:27:59 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 33
Fantasia Barino 4
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Katherine McPhee 0
Blake Lewis 23
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Fantaisa
-Katherine, Blake
|
|
|
|
Post by Kathleen Pace on Nov 28, 2008 16:30:52 GMT -6
Kelly Clarkson 34
Fantasia Barino 2
Carrie Underwood 51
Jordin Sparks 20
David Cook 24
Blake Lewis 23
David Archuleta 23
-------------------
8th: Katherine McPhee
9th: Taylor Hicks
10th: Diana DeGarmo
11th. Bo Bice
12th: Justin Guarrini
13th: Clay Aiken
14th: Ruban Studdard
+Kelly
-Fantasia
|
|
